To travel over road, train, air in the US you also must ID yourself. To get a mobile phone you have to ID yourself (and sign in-person for the package if a phone is delivered to you) in the US.
> To travel over road, train, air in the US you also must ID yourself.
No you don't. If I drive a car, I have to have license and show that if asked by the police but that is a requirement of driving. If I am a passenger, I don't have to have an ID. I can take an airplane flight without an ID, that has been shown time and time again. Taking the train and ID'ing yourself might be condition of being able to use a train, not law.
If I am out and about, I don't have to show the military my ID, I don't have to show security guards my ID and if I am not accused of a crime, I don't have to show the police my ID. Try that in China.
> To get a mobile phone you have to ID yourself (and sign in-person for the package if a phone is delivered to you) in the US.
Not true. I bought a T-Mobile SIM card with cash and activated it at home and I could have put anything into the address information. I have never once shown my ID when dealing with my T-Mobile account. Try doing that in China.
> I bought a T-Mobile SIM card with cash and activated it at home and I could have put anything into the address information. I have never once shown my ID when dealing with my T-Mobile account. Try doing that in China.
That's not hard to do in China (well, your SIM card would be China Mobile or China Unicom, not T-Mobile), unless they've made some drastic changes in the last couple of years. But since I've seen the claim that you had to provide ID to buy a SIM card made at times where I knew it was currently false, I strongly suspect it's still false.
I think they made the changes. I once had such an "over the counter" sim card but later changed to a monthly contract with my passport. But I remember seeing on the expat magazines "last chance to keep your SIM card active". At one point you had to provide ID or they just turned off the service.
Correct. I signed up with China Unicom last week, was required to use my passport, and was only allowed a single SIM card. Anonymity is nearly impossible.
We've all got anecdotes, so here's mine. I was asked for ID each time I wanted to modify my AT&T account with a rep, and as such I produced one in the form of driver's license. At a major city hotel late at night, I produced my ID to a security guard who otherwise would not let me in with just my room key. At an airport security check, being over 18, I produced a government-approved ID to board the flight.
Maybe there are ways around all this, just like how in China, I bought a monthly subscription (not just pre-paid) China Unicom SIM at an official outlet using cash with no ID, and took many train and bus rides with just a ticket in hand.
I don't know when you did this, but you can't buy a ticket on a train (not subway) in China without providing identification in any city someone would recognize (Beijing, Shanghai, Shenzhen, Xiamen, Chongqing, etc.). As a foreigner, if you exit any of those cities in a car, you must notify the authorities (which is a pain when the Factory is just outside... but the manufacturer will let you know before they let you stay).
This has been largely true for the last 10 years. The same is true for any bus that crosses provincial boundaries. That includes every major Chinese train station (excluding HK/TW) in every city most people can name. If someone else bought you a ticket, they put a fake (probably western) ID on it or they did a favor of using your ID without telling you (that's why they ask for your Passport#). Even the standard electronic purchase stalls only print out a ticket if you provide a China ID, or in a small number of cases a Passport. Everywhere else you have to stand in line to provide ID to the ticketing agent.
All patrons of a hotel must provide an ID (even if you are a non-paying guest) to check in. If it is a foreign ID, they must photocopy it and provide it to the authorities (including your visa information). If you stay at an AirBnB, you must check in at the local Police Station with your Passport/Visa. Not doing so is a crime punishable by imprisonment and revocation of your visa!
That isn't the same thing, and your anecdotes don't really mean anything; the parent's anecdotes act as a counterexample, which is all that is necessary to prove that ID isn't necessary, even if it's generally or often used.
AT&T is requiring you to show ID as a security measure, not because the US gov't requires it. You're talking about them using your ID for authentication, to protect you from someone impersonating you to make unwanted changes to your account. This does not preclude you from being able to walk into an AT&T (or T-Mobile) store and get an activated SIM card with cash and without showing ID.
Ditto for the hotel security guard check. If they had required your ID at check-in for any purpose other than authenticating you against their reservation record, then that would be a problem. If you could walk into the hotel without a reservation and pay for a room with cash without flashing ID, then the parent's point stands. (And even if you couldn't, this may just be a particular hotel's policy, which is fine. The point being made is that the government is not requiring this. There are plenty of hotels in the US that are perfectly happy with anonymous money.)
As for flights, there's definitely more government involved with ID'ing you, but you can absolutely fly without ID. You just need to go through extra security screening, which is a pain, but works just fine.
My experience in China is over a decade old, so I won't comment on that.
Proving identity to an AT&T rep or a hotel security guard in order to validate authorization to access your account or room is not the same thing as the government demanding your identity in order to go from place to place.
Yes, they both involve proving your identity but that is where the similarity ends.
> We've all got anecdotes, so here's mine. I was asked for ID each time I wanted to modify my AT&T account with a rep, and as such I produced one in the form of driver's license.
This is a security precaution to edit your account. It's a good thing and this is also not part of a condition of setting up the account.
> At a major city hotel late at night, I produced my ID to a security guard who otherwise would not let me in with just my room key.
Same thing as above. You have to show ID as part of security for the Hotel and it is not required by law.
> At an airport security check, being over 18, I produced a government-approved ID to board the flight.
You don't have to produce ID to fly. Again, this has been shown time and time again.
>To get a mobile phone you have to ID yourself (and sign in-person for the package if a phone is delivered to you) in the US.
You can buy a prepaid phone and minutes with cash in the US. I bought an Android phone and a minutes with a prepaid card just a month ago (with a credit card, but if I could have used cash), and activated it without giving any personal information.
You can buy and load data/minutes on SIM cards in the US with cash without an ID. I've had cell phones delivered from many different vendors without requiring signing for the package upon delivery, plus pre-paid phones are available for purchase with cash all over the place without the need to hand over personal information.
I can ride the light rail all over my city through buying a pass with cash. I can ride in the car between all 48 contiguous states without needing an ID. Going through TSA checkpoints or leaving/entering the country are the only forms of travel which require an ID or filing a form essentially equivalent to an ID.
> Well that is an exception to the rule rather than the norm.
It is? I've literally never given my ID on SFBART or Amtrak, what modes of travel besides being the driver of a car have you had to have a form of state or national ID?
Well that is an exception to the rule rather than the norm.
In China, you can also get temporary ID from train stations and airports if you misplaced it.
It is really funny for me to see comments like this used to show US being better than China, when all I see is the act of shooting yourself in the foot - "We don't need ID to travel, because we can exploit the exception made for losing or misplacing ID."
If you really want to compare the ability to exploit the system, I doubt US citizens can beat Chinese citizens.
> Well that is an exception to the rule rather than the norm.
It's a little disingenuous to compare the US and China in this way. In the US, air travel is literally the only form of transportation where an ID is (by convention) required. It is absolutely the norm when you are traveling in the US by car (as a passenger), bus, or train that you never show any form of ID, ever.
> In China, you can also get temporary ID from train stations and airports if you misplaced it.
I think it's telling that it's even possible to get a temp ID in China from so many places if you've misplaced yours. That tells me that having your ID at all times in China is a necessity, and not having it can cause you problems. In the US, if you lose your ID, it's annoying, but it's not a big deal to be without an ID for a while.
> If you really want to compare the ability to exploit the system, I doubt US citizens can beat Chinese citizens.
Ultimately you want to not have to exploit the system. In that it's just not necessary, because the system is fair, or at least there are efficient legal remedies when it's unfair. Obviously neither the US nor China have such great systems, but, again, I find it telling that the need to exploit the system is so great in China that it's so commonplace and everyone is so good at it. So I find your statement about that kinda sad, not a good thing.
I agree with your points, but I don't think you are replying to the points that I made directly. I was specifically referring to the TSA rule on verifying identity without ID and its intention, not on car, trains, or how prevalent the requirement of ID is in China. My point is, in terms of ID requirements for air travel, there is not much difference between the two country.
Then again, I am totally used to people getting angry when I say China is not necessarily worse than US in some aspect regardless of right or wrong.
If you really want to be genuine, try to read my comments with a fresh state of mind and see what I am trying to convey.
Ah, now I understand why the downvotes. I mean "not having ID and going through identity verification process" is considered an exception by TSA when boarding the plane, not a norm.
I didn't mean to say "not requiring an ID" is an exception to all forms of travel in the US. So please stop downvoting me if you understand what I mean.
