Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The President shouldn't be recommending unproven drugs, he should be communicating what we know and what to do now.


That's still not a partisan issue.


Then criticizing the President for promoting drugs that haven't been shown to work is non-partisan as well. Can't have it both ways.

I find the "political" vs "non-political" distinction facile anyways.


But the president is not just a mouthpiece, he needs to make decisions based on incomplete information. His administration seems to have opened up channels for trials and off-label usage.


> off-label usage

Off-label usage is bad when this is a drug that other people (like those with lupus - see here [0]) need to survive - we need trials first and I'm not sure that is occurring due to the President. This is a problem created by too early messaging when you should be focusing on "stay home" and other clear communication that was absent for weeks before his focus on this drug.

[0]: https://www.cnn.com/2020/03/31/opinions/hydroxychloroquine-c...


It seems like this thread has evolved from (1) the president was partisan in his statements about HCQ; (2) the president was political in his statements about HCQ; to (3) he jumped the gun on messaging.

Let's not let the media tear us apart. Not everything is Trump's fault. Not everything is America's fault. And sometimes people who are not Trump or countries that are not America make bad decisions that cost lives. Let's acknowledge these basic facts and work together.

California and Texas seem to be making better choices than NY and Florida. America seems to be doing better than Italy and Spain but worse than Germany. It's not really a partisan thing and it's not really a national identity thing. It's an issue of who in what regions acted strongly enough, and when.

America is a federal system, so we would expect variance between the states, and that's what we're seeing. Same as in Europe. The federal government plays an important role (like preventing test kits from being developed outside the CDC -- bad -- and early travel restrictions -- probably good), but not the only role, and it shows.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: