Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I'm Russian, and think so too. :-)

If you don't know Russian or Hebrew, how did you tell? Just curious.



I speak Hebrew.

I don't speak Russian, but I had a lot of Russian friends growing up. So I've heard a lot of jokes fall flat in translation from Russian. I thought I recognised the sound.


It's the type of humor (culturally Russian/culturally Jewish), not the actual wording.


Hey, that's why I asked - to learn how others see Russian culture from the outside. What's the defining quality.

?


The first joke - thoughtful irony (the plumber prides himself in being covered in shit - but is it worth it?). The second is very uniquely Russian (I only kind of get it) - somehow, vulgarity with a good comeback is funny. The third makes fun of overvaluing superficial social status (being in the aeroplane industry), which I could see as an internal stereotype of Jewish culture.


Explicitness


fatalism


Do you mean "fatalism" (a general acceptance of fate) or "defeatism" (a certain pessimistic variant of that acceptance) ?


More of the first. Some of the second. But the latter with a sort of sly smile.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: