Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Thank you. Why do some relays need to be public Internet hosts (if I understood correctly what I saw) instead of using all Tor hosts as relays? Sorry if the answer is somehow implicit in what you already posted.



Thanks for all your help and I understand if I've exhausted the efforts of free HN technical help!

I read the link and while I learned more about Tor, the article seems to describe how to secure Tor traffic that is forwarded to regular Internet hosts, for example if someone using a Tor client visited ycombinator.com. My question is, if you use a Tor client to visit twitterhpgjerufcvrmzerg2novpipy42rk3anvb5b7np4zggm4rwaqd.onion, why is part of the route through regular Internet hosts (afaict) and what are the implications of that? The article shows what I am describing in this screenshot; the blacked out parts next to "Portugal", "Germany", and "United States" are IP addresses:

https://www.jamieweb.net/blog/forwarding-tor-hidden-services...

(Also, my original post had it backward: the traffic goes through regular Internet hosts and then through Tor relays, not vice versa)

Again, maybe I am just missing the implications of what you are saying.


Yeah I was hoping someone would fill the in the details lol.


I think I cleared up what was left unmentioned here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30620496

I like your initial explanation sp332, I thought it was good so I elaborated on it.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: