Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

[flagged]


If you haven't heard of Rich Hickey, then you're fortunate to have the opportunity to watch "Simple Made Easy" for the first time: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=LKtk3HCgTa8


> A human writing twelve polemic questions, many of which only make sense within their ideological worldview or contain factual errors, because they wanted to vent their anger on the internet has been considered substandard slop since before LLMs were a thing.

Maybe by people who don't share the same ideological worldview.

I'll almost always take human slop over AI slop, even when the AI slop is better along some categorical axis. Of course there are exceptions, but as I grow older I find myself appreciating the humanity more and more.


What factual errors did you the human notice


Rich Hickey designed Clojure.


I asked Claude if it could design Clojure and it said yes. Maybe people like Hickey just aren't needed anymore.


Ironically it may only be able to do this because it has been trained on Hickey’s creation. This was one of his criticisms.


what has hickey been trained on? ;)


Years of experience working in Enterprise and complex systems.

And that is all on point with the criticism: while an AI can design a new language based in an existing language like Clojure, we need actual experienced people to design new interesting languages that add new constraints and make Software Engineering as a whole better. And we are also killing with AI the possibility of new people getting up to speed and becoming a future Rich Hickey.


> And we are also killing with AI the possibility of new people getting up to speed and becoming a future Rich Hickey.

Not sure I am on board with this part... I find LLMs in particular to be great teachers specifically for getting up to speed to becoming future Rich Hickey.


it is indeed a great teacher but there are times where it hallucinates and sticks to the hallucinated content even after several iteration unless human in the loop breaks it. i've wasted hours believing what LLM hallucinated.

my learnings are a lot of microdoses of things that I usually don't work on in a day to day so i don't want to spend time reading about it but yes this sort of learning would be otherwise impossible so gotta thank LLM for that.


Ask it to design something that don’t exist maybe. Asking it to design something that already exists is useless.


lmao surely this is sarcasm




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: