Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I totally agree with this article. I've been playing a lot of video games in the past, always with the T.V. on, all while doing my homeworks and reading my school notes. I failed a few classes during that period of my life, and I finished pre-university a year later than expected. It turns out that it didn't pay off at all.

At the moment, I'm in University while working full-time, and my grades are where they should have been years ago. I'm getting As most of the time, and I believe it has a lot to do with how I handle my tasks. Since I'm only doing two classes at a time, I try to focus on one a week, on the other the next. I try to never work on two different subjects on the same day and I even force myself to avoid reading some article and trying new things because it would take my focus away from what I really have to do.

Dedicating our attention on one subject at a time always turns out better.



Anecdotes like yours don't prove anything. That's why we have science.

Without a control group and test group we don't know if your conclusions are statistically valid. Maybe most people get better grades when they watch TV and play video games.


I probably mis-worded my thoughts. I did not meant "it's true for x therefore it's true for the whole set". It's definetly not something we can generalize. At least, we can say that he's not completely wrong.

Nevertheless, I still believe that if such study was conducted, it would tend in that direction. The actual difference between a multi-tasker and a uni-tasker might not be very large, there might even not be any difference in some cases. Considering how the memory supposedly works, I find it hard to believe that one would retain the equivalent amount of information while multi-tasking than while uni-tasking.

This is a study from 2007 that goes in the same direction. It focuses on the impacts of social networking sites on high-schooler grades. [pdf]http://www.iiisci.org/journal/CV$/sci/pdfs/E214BL.pdf


Isn't it just common sense that doing two things at once means you'll have less time for both?


To make a fair comparison, you have to factor in your video game and TV performance and productivity, which is obviously suffering now.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: