Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Talk about goalpost-moving. First you ask for apps that benefit from these kinds of optimizations. Then someone gives you an example and you say it isn't important because it probably doesn't have many users?

That's a catch-22. Apps like that can't have many users because the improvements they depend on aren't widely deployed. However, those improvements will never be widely deployed if people persuasively argue against their importance using evidence like a small user base...



Goalpost-moving? You mean in my OP where I asked whether it benefits the average user? Where I said that the majority of performance issues remain in the DOM?

I moved no goalpost. I am saying exactly what I always said. What the GP said that they are doing is almost certainly an ill-conceived project because JavaScript -- without a major change like asm.js -- simply cannot offer competitive performance as a facet of the language. Which is why we don't build a renderer in JavaScript, but instead layer it over WebGL, for instance.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: