Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

ha ha :) nice example for ad hominem.

The author is part of the Green party directly fighting the law you mentioned. Also if you cannot see the difference between the law Germany passed and what the US is doing with PRISM, you seem to be on the wrong website ;)



What makes you think German intelligence agencies don't have a similar program?


'but everyone does it' is no excuse for amoral behaviour.

Besides, if a country positions itself as the beacon of -foo- for the world, then it should lead by example, not hide behind "but everyone does it".


You think the German intelligence bugs embassies of other countries (and the UNO ??) and has secret deals wiht Google, Apple etc.?? I highly doubt it, the ramifications would be too high in case it became public. Anyhow, we are discussing US right now ... not Germany. (Check what ad hominem means :)


>You think the German intelligence bugs embassies of other countries (and the UNO ??) and has secret deals wiht Google, Apple etc.??

Yes, I do. Further, I think friendly intelligence agencies have data sharing agreements to get around laws against domestic spying.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: